FC 26 Ratings: Messi and Ronaldo, Legacy, and My Honest Reaction
I still remember the first time I opened the FC 26 ratings screen in 2026. I had my coffee, my controller, and that foolishly optimistic hope that maybe, just maybe, EA Sports would give Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo one more golden send-off. Instead, I got a cold dose of reality. Messi sits at 86. Ronaldo sits at 85. Both are downgrades. Neither is in the top 50. For two players who once felt bigger than the game itself, that stings.

The numbers that hit hard
Here is what I saw when the cards dropped:
| Player | FC 26 rating | Previous rating | The stat debate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lionel Messi | 86 | 88 | Passing rated 85 |
| Cristiano Ronaldo | 85 | 86 | Shooting rated 88 |
A year ago, Messi was rated 88 during his second season with MLS side Inter Miami. Ronaldo received an 86 after his first full season at Saudi Arabian club Al-Nassr. In 2026, those older ratings feel like a different era. Liverpool's Mohamed Salah and Real Madrid's Kylian Mbappe are the top two rated cards in this year's edition. That part makes sense to me. The game is rewarding the present, not the memory.
But no Messi or Ronaldo in the top 50? That is the line that broke fan timelines. I understand it. I also do not have to like it. 😅

Why the debate exploded
I scrolled through reactions and felt the split immediately. Some fans were furious that Ronaldo had better shooting at 88 than Messi at 85. One supporter wrote: 'The most silly is shooting, Messi has likely 99 and Ronaldo 82.' Another went harder: 'There's nothing Ronaldo has more than Messi.' I laughed, then sighed. I have seen this argument for more than a decade. It never ends.
Messi's passing rating at 85 also bothered people. One fan argued: 'I'd say Messi's passing should still be in the 90s, you don't lose that, no matter how old you are.' I get that. Vision and weight of pass are not tied to sprint speed. Another claimed both should still be among the best players in the game: 'Even in their current state they should be part of the top 50, especially for Messi.' And yes, someone called Ronaldo's 85 'criminal.' In 2026, football game ratings are not just numbers. They are memory, identity, and a little bit of grief.
The 99 club and the weight of history
I keep coming back to history. Messi and Ronaldo are the only players to ever receive a 99 rating in FIFA. Ronaldo did it in FIFA 18. Messi did it in FIFA 16. That is the air they used to breathe. They dominated FIFA titles with exceptional stats, and for years their cards were the first thing you checked. Now I check their cards and feel like I am reading a farewell note written in data.
But I also understand EA's side. In 2026, both are in the later stages of their careers. Ronaldo is at Al-Nassr. Messi is at Inter Miami. Their ratings broadly reflect current form, not eternal legend. Salah and Mbappe being top two fits the moment. The game is moving on. That does not mean fans have to like it.
My verdict
I think the mixed opinions are fair. I would push Messi's passing into the 90s. I would not call Ronaldo's 85 criminal, but I would call it harsh. And if I am honest, I would put both in or near the top 50, especially Messi, because their current level is still special in a game that rewards intelligence. Still, I cannot pretend this is FIFA 16 or FIFA 18. The icons are older. The ratings are lower. The debate is louder.
Maybe that is the real FC 26 story for me. Not just two downgraded cards, but two fanbases learning how to love legends after the peak. I will still use Messi. I will still try Ronaldo. And I will still argue about shooting and passing with my friends. Some habits do not fade, even when the ratings do. âš½
SportsIconLegends
Comments